Despite lower Tariffs, Policy Uncertainty Rises

 

Following the Supreme Court’s decision that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) cannot be used to implement tariffs, the Trump administration quickly shifted strategy, turning to Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974. Beginning February 24, temporary tariffs of 15% were introduced as a short-term “bridge” ahead of more permanent actions expected under Sections 301 and 232. While the immediate tariff burden may be slightly lower, the overall uncertainty surrounding trade policy has climbed to unprecedented levels.

The World Trade Policy Uncertainty Index has surged to nearly four times the peak levels seen during the 2018–19 US-China trade war. Tariffs introduced under Section 122 are capped at 15% and can only remain in place for 150 days, expiring on July 24 unless Congress votes to extend them. With prediction markets currently assigning an 85% probability that Democrats regain control of the House, securing Congressional approval for an extension ahead of midterm elections appears politically unlikely.

Under the Section 122 framework, the effective average tariff rate is estimated to ease to roughly 11%, compared with about 13% under the previous IEEPA structure. This reduction largely reflects exemptions for critical minerals, pharmaceuticals, USMCA-compliant goods, and selected agricultural products. However, once the longer-term tariffs under Sections 301 and 232 are finalised by late July, the effective rate is expected to move back toward 13%.

The legal basis of Section 122 itself may also face scrutiny. The provision was originally designed to address “large and serious balance-of-payments deficits,” a condition some analysts argue is not fully met despite the record $901 billion US trade deficit recorded in 2025. Legal challenges are widely expected, although courts are unlikely to reach a ruling before the July deadline. On the fiscal side, up to $175 billion in tariff revenues collected under IEEPA since last April may need to be refunded, potentially widening the federal deficit by around 10%.

For now, bond markets have remained relatively calm, but equities and cryptocurrencies have shown greater volatility, reflecting uncertainty about policy direction rather than the tariff levels themselves.

Bottom line: Near-term tariff levels may be slightly lower, but trade policy uncertainty has increased sharply. The administration’s negotiating leverage appears weaker, potential tariff refunds could strain fiscal balances, and expectations of a swift pivot toward tax cuts have faded — at least for the moment.


   Click “here” to download paper or contact us to get more details.